Loading...
KODIAK TWNST BK 8 LT 6A,B,C - Parking Plan Review (4)MATTHEW D. JAMIN C. WALTER EBELL JOEL H. BOLGER• DIANNA R. GENTRY ALAN L. SCHMITT WALTER W. MASON•• DUNCAN 5. FIELDS flOMITTED TO WASHINGTON •NO ALASKA BARS • flOMITTED TO MINNESOTA ADMITTED OALASKA BAP <e JAMIN, EBELL, BOLGER & GENTRY A PROFESSIONAL CORPORATION ATTORNEYS AT LAW 323 CAROLYN STREET KODIAK, ALASKA 99615 FACSIMILE: (907) 466-6112 TELEPHONE: (907) 466-6024 REPLY TO KODIAK OFFICE May 7, 1990 SEATTLE OFFICE: 09 FIRST AVENUE SOUTH SUITE 460. MAYNARO BUILDING SEATTLE. WASHINGTON 9E004 FACSIMILE: (206) 6230521 TELEPHONE: (206) 622.7634 I 6 Mr. Duane Dvorak Community Development Dep-_rtment Kodiak IslandjBorough 710 Mill Bay Road Kodiak, AKt99E15 RE: Kodiak Island. Borough v. LeDoux Our File No. 4095-87 Dear Duane•: Please find enclosed copies of the appeal documents filed by Kurt LeDoux. :Gabrielle LeDoux did mention to me that the LeDouxs may be willing to dismiss their appeal if we would agree to give up our claim for attorney's fees and costs. Please 1)et me know if the Borough would be interested in pursuing this, alternative. Sincerely yours, JAMIN, EBELL, BOLGER & GENTRY DO ,yaj.l3.:3, be_ H. Bolger RECEIVED MAY 8 —1.990 COMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT DEPT 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 26 27 28 LeDOUX & LeDOUX ATTORNEYS AT LAW 2191Aµ BA !ROAD KODIAK. ALASKA 99815 (907) 488.4082 Attorneys for IIN THE SUPERIOR COURT FOR THE STATE OF ALASKA A KODIAK ISLAND BOROUGH Pl1intiff, vs. KURT M.`LeDOUX and GABRIELLE LeDOUX, - DEFENDANTS A roi oaaieno! Co:perotien APR 2513 KODIAK, ALASKA THIRD JUDICIAL DISTRICT AT KODIAK Defendants. ) ) 3K0-89-210 Civil NOTICE OF APPEAL Defendants Kurt M. LeDoux and Gabrielle LeDoux of 219 Mill Bay Road,;Kodiak, Alaska hereby give notice of their appeal to the Alaska Supreme Court from the Summary Superior Court entered on January 12, 1990, Motion 'for Summary Judgment, the Judgment 1990, the:Order Awarding Attorney's fees, Judgment Order of the granting Plaintiff's entered on March 22, entered on March 22, 1990, and the clerk's taxation of costs, entered on April 18, 1990. RESPECTFULLY SUBMITTED this ,i r)day of April, 1990 I I ledoux.3\notice.app certlt► flet ea 1 _ a e► e1 1 V ..t r5t served a t ve 'ana aortal' ceP► et the agave on each attorney i record in Ihh math; • LeDOUX .& LeDOUX ATTORNEYS A t ' . Lei": x, Artorne for De dents NOTICE jOF!APPEAL; Case No. 3K0-89-210 Civil; page 2 1 3 5 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 .25 26 27 28 leDaUX & L ROUX ATTORNEYSAT{AW JAPriIN, L -U-... PALL 0UL f. 219 KODIAK Y ROAO A Pro es;lon:j COt ., r'�:l 11, f KODIAK 4ASKA 99815 Fv*alio (907) 486-4082 1 I APR 2, 5 :; J Anomeys for , KODIAK ALAS 1 1 DEFENDANTS KA IINITHE SUPERIOR COURT FOR THE STATE OF ALASKA THIRD JUDICIAL DISTRICT AT KODIAK KODIAK ISLAND BOROUGH ) Plaintiff, ) vs. , ) ) KURT M. lLeDOUX and ) GABRIELLE LeDOUX, ) Defendants. ) ) 3K0-89-210'Civil POINTS ON APPEAL Defendants Kurt M. LeDoux and Gabrielle LeDoux hereby submit their points on appeal as follows: 1.'The Trial Court erred in granting Plaintiff's Motion for Summary Judgment. 2.GThe Trial Court erred in granting Plaintiff's Motion f for Summary Judgment when there were material disputed facts to be resolved. 3.1The Trial Court erred in granting Plaintiff relief not pleadedior requested before Plaintiff's hearing on its motion for summary judgment. 4. 'The Trial Court denied Defendants due process when it granted Plaintiff relief not pleaded or requested before Plaintiff's hearing on its motion for summary judgment. 5. 'Defendants did not receive adequate notice and hearing that Plaintiff was going to seek alternative relief than what was pleaded or requested by Plaintiff. 6.'The Trial Court erred in entering judgment before the case was totally resolved. 7. Th'e Trial Court erred in entering judgment in favor of Plaintiff.! 8. The Trial Court erred in awarding Plaintiff attorney's fees and costs. 9. The Trial Court erred in failing to award Defendants attorney's fees and costs. 10f. ,The Trial Court erred in awarding Plaintiff an excessive amount of attorney's fees. 1 11. The Trial Court erred in awarding Plaintiff attorney's fees for unnecessary legal work. RESPECTFULLY SUBMITTED thi � earfllt, 1f served a' true 811 eeriest illeraevief inert_ •f the above •n eeeg �. _ f2A ' lila Netter'( raj ledoux.3\points POINTS'ONfAPPEAL; Case No. ay of April, 1990. LeDOUX & LeDOUX ATTORNEYS AT LAW I_. , abl► kir; ' ur i M r LeDou� A t'rne BY: Defen•ants 3K0-89-210 Civil; page 2 0 1 2 3 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 26 27 28 • LeDOUX & LenOUX ATTORNEYSAT LAW 219 MILL 6AY,AOAO KODIAK, ALASKA 996tS fe07) 4864082 Attorneys for • IN; THE SUPERIOR DEFENDANTS JAittiit A Prctes;;onoLC'r;4 4i;14iti srmien APR 2513,0 KOD/AK AutS icit COURT FOR THE STATE OF ALASKA THIRD JUDICIAL DISTRICT KODIAK ISLAND BOROUGH Plaintiff, vs. KURT M.'LeDOUX and GABRIEIJ F LeDOUX, Defendants. 3K0-89-2101 Civil AT KODIAK DESIGNATION OF RECORD COMES:NOW Defendants Kurt M. LeDoux and Gabrielle LeDoux, and they hereby designate as their record on appeal the entire Superior Curt file, and transcripts of .1 court proceedings RESPECTFULLY SUBMITTED 1 esstilr trot os los,_.._ dor e1 0N served a traeiana correct' DPI 0 the above on each attorney •f record la eager this ;nattily 01 wad W xo4' OO4W,7✓ _ ledoux.3\design this +ay of April, 1990. LeDOUX & LeDOUX ATTORNEYS M. eb:ux fo Defendants • MATTHEW D. JAMIN C. WALTER EBELL JOEL H. BOLGER• DIANNA R. GENTRY ALAN L. SCHMITT WALTER W. MASON•• DUNCAN S. FIELDS •ADMITTER TO WASHINGTON ALASKAAMR BARS TOMINNESOTA BAR ALL OTHERS TTEO TOALASKA BAR JAMIN, EBELL, BOLGER & GENTRY A PROFESSIONAL CORPORATION ATTORNEYS AT LAW 323 CAROLYN STREET KODIAK, ALASKA 99615 FACSIMILE: (907) 406-6112 TELEPHONE: (907) 406-6024 REPLY TO KODIAK OFFICE May 1, 1990 Mr. Duane .Dvorak Kodiak Island1Borough . 710 Mill Bay Road Kodiak, AK;'99615 RE: Kodiak Island Borough LeDoux Case No. 3K0-89-210 CIV Our File No. 4095-87 • SEATTLE OFFICE: 119 FIRST AVENUE SOUTH SUITE 460, MAYNARD BUILDING SEATTLE. WASHINGTON 90104 FACSIMILE: (206) 623-7521 TELEPHONE: (206) 6227634 Dear Duane; Enclosed herewith is a copy of the Objection to Surety Bond regarding the above -referenced matter. Sincerely yours, JAMIN, EBELL, BOLGER & GENTRY JHB:.dlm Enclosures. 1 I cc: Honorable Jerome Selby, Mayor Kodiak Island Borough RECEIVED MAY 2 -1990 ICONNUNITY DEVELOPNEN1 DEPT JAMIN. EBEtJ. BOLGER & GENTRY 323 CAROLER STREET KODIAK. AK 996t5 (907) 466.6024 IN THE TRIAL COURTS FOR THE STATE OF ALASKA THIRD JUDICIAL DISTRICT AT KODIAK KODIAK nISLAND BOROUGH, ) I ) ^ Plaintiff, ) ©(t ) I ) ) ) KURT M.' LEDOUX and ) GABRIELLE,R. LEDOUX ) ) Defendants, ) b ) ) Case N&f. 3K0-89-210 CIV OBJECTION TO SURETY BOND Kodiak Island Borough, by counsel, objects to the surety bond submitted by the defendants on the basis that no attorney at I i law or other officer of the court is qualified to be a surety on •I an appeal'bond. Civil Rule , DATED this ay of April, 1990. 80(b). JAMIN, EBELL, BOLGER & GENTRY Attorneys for Plaintiff Certificate of Service The undersigned hereby certifies that a true and correct copy of the foregong,document was served upon the fol'lorling by mail on the fa day ofApril, 1990. Kurt M. LeDoux GabrielileR. LeDoux 219 Mill Bay Road Kodiak,, AK 99615 Si(4) %27t7nic, JAMIN, .EBELL, BOLG 4095\87P.036 ! & GENTRY JAMIN, EBELL, BOLGER & GENTRY MATTHEW D. JAMIN C. WALTER EBELL JOEL H. BOLGER• DIANNA R. GENTRY ALAN L. SCHMITT WALTER W. MASON•• DUNCAN 5. FIELDS TACIPTITTED TO WASHINGTON ANO ALASKA BARS •• MINNESOTA BAR u OTHERS ADMITTED TO ALASAA BAR Mr. Duane Dvorak Kodiak IslandlBorough 710 Mill Bay Road Kodiak, AK 99615 RE: A PROFESSIONAL CORPORATION ATTORNEYS. AT LAW 323 CAROLYN STREET KODIAK, ALASKA 99615 FACSIMILE: (907) 486-6112 TELEPHONE: (907) 486.6024 REPLY TO KODIAK OFFICE April 19, 1990 SEATTLE OFFICE: 119 FIRST AVENUE SOUTH SUITE 460. MAYNARD BUILDING SEATTLE. WASHINGTON 98104 FACSIMI LE: 1206)623.7521 TELEPHONE: (206) 622-7634 Kodiak Island Borough v. Kurt M. LeDoux and Gabrielle R. LeDoux - Case No. 3K0-89-210 CIV Our:File No. 4095-87 Dear Duane: Enclosed herewith is a copy of the Clerk's Taxation of Costs and Judgment regarding the above -referenced matter. Sincerely yours, JAMIN, EBELL, BOLGER & GENTRY oel H. Bolge JHB:dlm Enclosures cc: Honorable Jerome Selby, Mayor Kodiak Island Borough fiteriVED APR 2O0 • COMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT DEPT A Proles$KX' CorPCra APR 18199[ KODIAK, ALAS 1 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 on THE SUPERIOR COURT FOR T1x_ STATE OF ALASKA THIRD JUDICIAL DISTRICT AT KODIAK .JKODIAK ISLAND BOROUGH, ) Plaintiff, ) vs. ) ) KURT M. LEDOUX and ) GABRIELLE R. LEDOUX, ) Defendants. ) Case No. 3K0-89-210 CI Ly FALE(] rr:, Alaska Trial Courts third Judicial District at Kodiak APR 171990 Clerk of lho Trial Cw:: DEPUTY CLERK'S TAXATION OF COSTS Plaintiff's Bill of Costs came on for hearing before the,Clerk on the 10th day of April, 1990; Plaintiff appearing by Joel Bolger and Defendants appearing by Gabrielle LeDoux. After considering objections and responses, the Clerk makes the following rulings: Western Alaska Land Title Company - Title Report: Defendant argues that this cost should not be allowed as it was not a necessarily incurred cost. Plaintiff responded that it was necessitated to verify owners as well as to obtain thelegaldescription of the property in question. The Clerk requested verifying documentation and after having received it allows this cost. Alaska Department of Revenue - Certified copy of Deed: The Defendant again argued that this was not a necessarily incurred cost. Plaintiff responded that this certified copy supported his Motion for Summary Judgment andiwas required pursuant to Civil Rule 56(e). The Clerk allows this cost. Westlaw charges/Computer Research: These costs are denied by the Clerk, however, they may be brought before the ;court by separate motion for consideration. Alaska Court System Telephone charges: Long distance telephone charges between Plaintiff's Kodiak office and Seattle office are disallbwed. Costs are taxed in favor of Plaintiff, Kodiak Island' Borough and against Defendants, Kurt M. LeDoux and Gabrielle R. LeDoux as follows: 199 Filing and Service Fees Postage Photocopies Certified copy of deed Title Report $ 76.00 31.25 30.90 3.50 157.50 TOTAL COSTS $ 299-.15 Dated at Kodiak, Alaska this 17th day of April i A. Wade Clerk of Court S Page -2- Clerk's Taxation of Costs 3KOL89i210 CI Kodiak Island Borough v LeDoux IIII i CC�!if1. rq / _ /D - 90 " Alaska Court System n ;>; .t!'; _ . :io r.^.: >,ei: ad,re Dept:ty Clerk JAMfla, E �_,u A Profession ICorperafion APR 1 s 1993 IN THE TRIAL COURTS FOR THE STATE OF ALASKA THIRD JUDICIAL DISTRICT AT KODIAK KODIAK, ALASKA , KODIAKIISLAND BOROUGH, I 1 1 : Plaintiff, vs.; { ) KURT M4 LEDOUX and ) MAR 2 i =;;t) GABRIEI;LE.R. LEDOUX ) I ) ' Defendants, DEPUTY JAMIN. EBELL BOLGER B GENTRY 323 CAROLYN STREET KODIAK. AK 99615 (907) 488.6024 ) Case NcS. 3K0-89-210 CIV 1 JUDGMENT Summary Judgment having been entered in favor of the plaintiff, Kodiak Island Borough, IT IS HEREBY ORDERED that plaintiff, Kodiak Island Borough, is entitled to an award of reasonable attorney fees pursuant to CR 82 and to its costs pursuant to CR 54 (d). I Accordi;ngiy, plaintiff is awarded attorney fees in the amount of $ 3,35d CP - and costs inthe amount of $ the total i Judgment of $ 65/9. 3' c399. /5 for This Judgment will accrue interest at 0.1A1/9147 the_ rate ofSten Qa(nld one-half percent (10.5%). ` 1 DATED :- 6 )1.& � coq 1 / ( 7 t certify that On �67J -90 a copy °tribe a^ove a •ss mailed to each :t the fallowing heiraddrese of record;. Deputy Clerk ROY H. f' DSEN Superior Court Judge JUDGMENT - Page 1 Case No. 3K0-89-210 CIV / pp 1onliN the nn ofrec..r::itse r -L,/ (i�drr1G .D: i;'. , :2e: MATTHEW D. JAMIN C. WALTER EBELL JOEL H. BOLGER• DIANNA R. GENTRY ALAN L. SCHMITT •AIDNIITTED TO WASHINGTON ALAS•A BARS ALL OTHERS ADMITTED TO ALASKA BAP JAMIN, EBELL, BOLGER & GENTRY A PROFESSIONAL CORPORATION ATTORNEYS AT LAW 323 CAROLYN STREET KODIAK, ALASKA 99615 FACSIMILE: (907) 486-6112 TELEPHONE: (907) 486-6024 REPLY TO KODIAK OFFICE March 26, 1990 SEATTLE OFFICE: 119 FIRST AVENUE SOUTH SUITE 320, MAYNARD BUILDING SEATTLE, WASHINGTON 98104 FACSIMILE: (208) 623-5818 TELEPHONE: (208) e22-,634 JOEL H. BOLGER Mr. Duane Dvorak Community Development Department Kodiak Island ;Borough 710 Mill Bay Road Kodiak, Alaska 99615 RE: Kodiak Island Borough v. LeDoux Our (File No. 4095-87 Dear Duane: Please! find enclosed a copy of the court's Summary Judgment Order of January 12, 1990, requiring the LeDoux's to construct or provide parking at their business premises. Also enclosed is a copy of the court's Judgment and of the court's Order Awarding Attorney's Fees, dated March 22, 1990. I will be submitting a Bill of Costs to'recover the Borough's out-of-pocket expenses within the next two weeks. Once the costs are approved, we will recover the attorney's fees and costs judgment and forward the balance to the Borough. Feel free to call if you have any questions. 0. I JHB:dlm Enclosures cc: Mr. Jerome Selby Mr. Robert Scholze 4095\87L.007 Sincerely yours, JAMIN, EBELL, BOLGER & GENTRY RFCF IED MAR 217 MU COMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT DEPT JAMIN, i A Profe al Corporalion MA 2 21990 KODAK, ALASKA JAMIN. EBELL BOLGER & GENTRY 313 CAROLYN HAM KODIAK. AK 99615 (907) 496.6024 IXg IN'THE SUPERI R COURT FOR THE STATE OF ALASKA THAI D JUDICIAL .DISTRICT KODIAK ISLAND BOROUGH, Plaintiff, 1 vs. KURT M. L'EDOUX and' GABRIELLE R. LEDOUX 1 Defendants. Case I f The 'court fees and the opposition to IS THEREFORE ORERED that the plaintiff shall have judgment I • attorneys! fees aga 3 35DCD AT KODIAK By' F i ED 13•,1 Aloka 7i Cc;irta Third ., 3.clal DizZrici MAR 2 . rr+. Clerk i to : nai CoerY; DEPUTY ORDER['WARDING ATTORNEYS FEES has considered the plaintiff's motion for attorneys evidence and arguments submitted in support and in that motion IT DONE nst the defendants in the amount of pursuant to't11vil Rule 82. this c�G� clay ofiL'4t 1990. 95\87P.02 1 certify,that on a copy of 13e n' vv.2:u each of the following a of record: tO 11 n I 1 -90 1'rrY11?' 211 Lint: •: 1 imp Deputy Clerk ROY DSEN Superi•r Court Judge JA a N, LG: A PI&msio MAR KODIA JAMIN. EBELL BOLGER & GENTRY SSS CAROt1N STRUT KODIAK. AK 98813 {90TI 189-8024 3_rl u b eN l orporotion. 21330 IN THE TRIAll i 1 ALASKA THIRD (JUDICIAL i KODIAK 'ISLAND BOROUGH,u Plaintiff, COURTS FOR THE STATE OF ALASKA KURT M.1 LEDOUX and GABRIELI E (R. ,LEDOUX i Defendants,1; Case No:. 3K0-89-210 CIU 1 Summary Judg plaintiff,' Kodiak Islan 1 IT IS HEREB II is entitled to an award of reasonable attorney fees i to 'CR 82 and to its costs pursuant to CR 54 (d). Accordingly, plaintiff as awarded attorney fees in the amount of $ 3,3509and hosts in the amount of $ for Borough, pursuant DISTRICT AT KODIAK ) ) ) ) MAR 2 . ) ) FILED IN Alae Thai o :ria Thin :,uu;c:; ! `Eit:rict t_ a: ._v01; ) ) Clea, I..ai Cour:.; By DEPUTY ilc g JUDGMENT ent having been entered in favor of the Borough, ORDERED that plaintiff, Kodiak Island the total Lludgment of $' This Judgment will accrue interest at the'rate of q ten and one-half percent (10.5%). :DATEDQJtJ as l Il( i1 ?certify That on J' o?.) 90 a copy of the above was mailed to each of thelfollowing at heir ad of record: 44 dAeputy Clark JUDGMENT -'Page 1 Case No) 3K0-89-210 CIV 4 ROY H. t • DSE Superior Court Judge JAfltl`J, -.. -2:- A Pr�lesrion< JAN 1 KODIAK JAMIN. EBELL BOLGER & GENTRY 3E3 CAROLYN STREET KODIAK. AK 99615 (907)966.6024 1' 1 Corporclion 1990 1 IN ALASKA 1 Ir A- rLog d_ma � jOA6-'t1 Goo THE SUPERI R COURT FOR THE STAT FILEDIN �}a�`rrl)1SawIFA li ThIro Jur!Icla! .i. t'Ict T D JUDICIAL DISTRICT a' r "'' KODIAK ISLAND BOROUGH, 1 Plaintiff, v. I 1 t ! KURT M. LEDOUX and GABRIELLE RI. LEDOUX I Defendants. 4 Case No.;3K9-89-210 Civi i 1 e court I 1 summary judgment and the il and in opposition to tha ! I propertyyhich!the defen AT KODIAK Bay Road; Kodiak, Alaska 1 Lot six (6), according to in the Kodia District, St ) ) )) ) ) SUMMARY JUDGMENT ) ) ) ) ) ) JAN 1 2 g90 Clerk of Me Trial Court By DEPUTY IKB s considered the plaintiff's motion for vidence and arguments submitted in support motion. This action involves certain real ;nts own, commonly referred to as 219 Mill snd more particularly described as: Block eight (8), Kodiak Town Site the Plat of U.S. Survey 25378B located Recording District, Third Judicial to of Alaska (hereinafter "Property"). The court! finds that thea is no dispute as to any material fact and that plaintiff is entitle • to a judgment as a matter of law. � 1 The defendati s, have on November 10, 1989 submitted an applicatib n 't to. the Plan, ng and Zoning Commission for an alternate { II I parking location pursuant'to KIBC 17.50.030. The Planning and Zoning I i Commission denied the de -ndants' application on December 20, 1989. II The defendants plan toI'-ppeal the Planning and Zoning Commission 1 l decision to the Kodiak City Council sitting as Board of Adjustment. 1 JAMIN. EBELL BOLGER & GENTRY 323 CARDLYN STREET KODIAK. AK 99615 (907) 406.6024 follows: IT IS THER 1L The def an alternate parking loca and timely manner; 2. Follo Adjustment or any timely shall discontinue the u{8 1 I building untilithey const the property pursuant to I Code and! the parking pl I provide an ,alternate pa which is,approved by the 1 by the court upon review upon remand; 3. The pia attorneys fees pursuant t DONE this d_ f I certify that. crt' a copy of I ilk' o7r P a' "Pi eac`.• t L',.. of recto.::.: /1.2-9© Daft:.; -- - SUMMARY JUDGMENT - Page 2 No.3K0-89-210Ci.v 4095\87P.024 ' ikg ORE, ORDERED, ADJUDGED and DECREED as ndants will prosecute their appeal regarding ion to the Board of Adjustment in a diligent g a final decision of the. Board of urt appeal of that decision, the defendants of the property as a professional office uct eight (8) off-street parking spaces on he provisions of the Kodiak Island Borough they previously submitted or until they g location, pursuant to KIBC 17.57.030 inal decision of the Board of Adjustment, or by the Planning and Zoning Commission ntiff may move for an award of costs and the prov- ions of the Civil Rules. day of 0 H. $ I'1 DSEN Superii. Court Judge r JAMIN. EBELL BOLGER & GENTRY 323 CAROLYN STREET K00IAK. AK 99615 (907) 496.6024 IX$ c rtificate of Service II The, undersigned } reby certifies that a true and correct copy I of the f4 regoing document 'was served on the F 'rday of Janua y, 1990. Kurt LeDoux, Esq. LeDOUX &;LeDOUX 219 MiliLBay Road Kodiak, Alaska' 99615 JAM N, EBELL, BOLGER & GENTRY SUMMARY JUDGMENT - Page 3 No.3K0-89-210Civ 4095\87P.024 I upon the following by mail/hand