Loading...
2014-06-26 Work Session Kodiak Island Borough Assembly Work Session Thursday, June 26, 2014, 7:30 p.m., Borough Conference Room Work Sessions are informal meetings of the Assembly where Assembly members review the upcoming regular meeting agenda packet and seek or receive information from staff.Although additional items not listed on the work session agenda are discussed when introduced by the Mayor,Assembly,or staff,no formal action is taken at work sessions and items that require formal Assembly action are placed on regular Assembly meeting agenda. Citizen's comments at work sessions are NOT considered pan of the official record.Citizen's comments intended for the"official record"should be made at a regular Assembly meeting. Page 1 . CITIZENS' COMMENTS (Limited to Three Minutes per Speaker) 2. AGENDA ITEMS 3 - 16 a. Engineering and Facilities Update to the Assembly a Engineering & Facilities Update.pdf Kodiak High School Renovation.pdf 17 - 30 b. Use of Facilities Fund for Interfund Loan a Facilities Fund Interfund Loan.pdf • Proposed Bond Proiects.pdf • 3. PACKET REVIEW PUBLIC HEARING Ordinance No. FY2014-19 Requesting the Inclusion of the Newly Constructed Residence Located at Lot 8, Block 1, Lakeside Subdivision First Addition and the Residence Located at Lot 7, Block 2, Akhiok Townsite in the Existing Payment in Lieu of Tax (PILT) Agreement with Kodiak Island Housing Authority. Ordinance No. FY2014-20 Amending Title 2 Administration and Personnel Chapter 2.30 Rules of the Assembly Section 2.30.080 Decorum in Debate Section 2.30.090 Citizens' Rights. NEW BUSINESS CONTRACTS Contract No. FY2015-01 Providence Kodiak Island Counseling Center Services to Kodiak Island Borough School District for School Year 2014- 2015. Contract No. FY2015-04 Destination Marketing and Tourism Development Services for FY2015. OTHER ITEMS Waive and Release Attorney-Client Privileged Documents With Respect to the Facilities Inter-fund Loans. Page 1 of 30 4. MANAGER'S COMMENTS 5. CLERK'S COMMENTS 6. MAYOR'S COMMENTS 7. ASSEMBLY MEMBERS COMMENTS Page 2 of 30 AGENDA ITEM #2.a. KODIAK ISLAND BOROUGH age-•-•i age- •-•ie DEPARTMENT of ENGINEERING and FACILITIES irt�tj f"'; Robert Tucker,Director 5ji ff$ i rtucker @kodiakak.us DATE: June 23,2014 TO: Borough Mayor and Assembly FROM: Robert Tucker, Director RE: Engineering and Facilities Department Update • This memo is to provide an update on the Engineering and Facilities Department projects and work plan for the Assembly's June 26, 2014 work session. Unfilled Department Positions The Department still has three unfilled positions; Maintenance Coordinator, Environmental Specialist,and a Project Manager position.This is becoming very concerning to me, as I have had several potential applicants tell me that the pay schedule is just too low. The Environmental Specialist has been vacant for over six months and only two applicants have been received neither were truly qualified. The Project Manager position has been empty for more than four months and no applicants have applied.The Maintenance Coordinator position does have a potential applicant that we are working with to fill. Maintenance Team Our maintenance team is continuing their efforts in maintaining our facilities. This includes everything within our preventive maintenance efforts that include not only routine checks, to involved cleaning or"pigging"of all the sea water intake lines for the research facility. They also are working on the routine maintenance that needs to be accomplished in the summer to prepare for another winter. New Garbage Rate Increase The new rates are being calculated by Alaska Waste.A letter will be sent out to all users stating why these increases are happening. The increases will take effect after the new fee schedule has been adopted by the Assembly. Page 3 of 30 Engineering and Facilities Update to the Assembly AGENDA ITEM #2.a. Monashka Bay and Bay View Road Service Contracts These contracts were not renewed this year because the service area hoards wanted to try to seek out a less expensive contract. The contracts were rewritten with the input from the boards and put out for bid. There were five bidders for the contract Brechan Enterprise is the apparent low bidder but this needs to be verified and discussed at the next service area board meetings. The contracts are now going to the Service Area Boards for review and will be brought to the Assembly at the next available assembly meeting. There does appear to be some cost saving to the service areas. Panamaroff Creek Playground The Assembly has approved the contract for the purchase of the playground equipment. The equipment has been placed into production and as soon as we receive the equipment we will begin installing the equipment. We are presently looking into a community build project for the installation. If we have the resources and the interest we will go in this direction. If not,we will go out to bid for the installation. We have the funding for the installation but if we can do it with a community build then the park has some community ownership and the remaining funds can be used on another park. Kodiak High School An update of the Kodiak High School project will be given by our contracted project manager, Bruce Walter at this meeting. Landfill Lateral Expansion Phase II of the Landfill Lateral Expansion project continues with, installation of a new high- density polyethylene liner for the new landfill cell and a new 37,000 sf holding pond is nearly complete. Brechan is also proceeding with closure of the existing landfill area. Phase 11 is scheduled to be completed by September 20,2014 Phase III,constructing the leachate treatment plant, is ongoing.The third of nine concrete pours for the stab and walls for the concrete tanks have been completed. The underground communication and electrical conduits from the baler building down to the Phase III site are in progress.Phase III is scheduled to be completed by May 31,2015. Kodiak Fisheries Research Center Ventilation Modification The Kodiak Fisheries Research Center ventilation system modification is well underway. The federal government will reimburse KIB for a portion of the construction costs through a lease amendment with GSA for the NOAA occupied space in the building. The project began work in early April 2014. All new mechanical fans and ductwork have been completed and installation of lighting occupancy sensors throughout the building is almost complete. Construction needs to be completed no later than July 15, 2014 to comply with GSA funding requirements. We see no reason at this point for the contractor not to finish on time. Page 4 of 30 Engineering and Facilities Update to the Assembly AGENDA ITEM #Z.a. Chiniak School Oil Tank Replacement This is for the removal of two underground tanks, 12,000 gallon and a 500 gallon that will be replaced with a 3,000 gallon above ground tank. KIB staff has received approval from the Alaska Department of Environmental Conservation to close the existing 12,000 gallon tank in place and not have to incur the expense of removing it front the ground. The contract has been approved and planning is now underway. To save time KIB has proceeded with procuring the new 3,000 gallon tank so it will be on site when the contractor is ready to start construction. This project needs to be completed by the end of the summer for startup of school in the fall. Anton Larsen Bay Dock The geotechnical investigation, design, permitting, and construction administration inspections was approved by the Assembly on June 5, 2014. The geotechnical work will be scheduled for June/July 2014. Public meetings were held in March 2014 both in town and in nearby villages. The architect and engineers are planning to proceed with design of the new dock in an identical location as the existing dock. The base bid will be for a sixty-foot-long dock section, with an alternate bid for a second sixty-foot-long section. Kodiak Middle School Concrete This is the final project to be completed from the 2004 GO bond issue. The scope consists of repairs to concrete walls and walkways surrounding Kodiak Middle School. Construction started June 3,2014, and is scheduled to he completed by August 15,2014 Fire Protection No. I Emergency Generator • The Assembly approved a design contract with RSA Engineering on February 20, 2014. RSA completed 95% design documents for this project which were reviewed and approved by the Architectural/Engineering Review Board (ARS) on May 20, 2014. The project was put out for bid June 24,2014,with bids due July 15,2014. Four School Generators The architect and engineers have completed 95% design development documents which were reviewed and approved by the ARB on May 20, 2014. The project went out to bid starting June 4, 2014, with bids due June 26, 2014. Due to the long lead time for shop drawings and manufacturing the generators, the plan is to complete Port Lions and North Star Elementary by January 2015 and Karluk and Old Harbor in summer 2015. Women's Bay Fire Hall Emergency Shelter Addition The Architect has completed conceptual design of a 3,500 square foot addition including a 1,000 square foot day room for community events and activities, double-wide apparatus bay to serve two fire engines, toilet room, and storage rooms. The 35% schematic design documents were completed,which were approved by the ARB on May 20, 2014.The architect has completed the environmental assessment required by the HUD grant, and should have 65% design documents completed this week. Page 5 of 30 Engineering and Facilities Update to the Assembly AGENDA ITEM #2.a. Lake Orbin Culvert Replacement. This project is a collaborative effort between the Kodiak Soil and Water Conservation District (KSWCD) and KIB. KSWCD received a grant from the United States Fish and Wildlife Service for replacement of a culvert leading from Lake Orbin to Russian River, in order to aid fish passage. KSWCD will provide the funding to MB and KIB will bid and manage the project.The contract has been awarded to Golden Alaska Excavating. Port Lions School Exterior Paint This project is painting the exterior of Port Lions School. This project was scheduled to go out for bid in February 2014 with the work completed during the summer of 2014,but is currently on hold pending the review of the use of the Facilities Fund for renewal and replacement projects. East and Peterson Flooring This project is removal and replacement of flooring at East and Peterson Elementary Schools. This project was scheduled to go out to bid in early 2014, with construction in the summer of 2014, but is currently on hold pending the review of the use of the Facilities Fund for renewal and replacement projects. Borough Building Renovation This project is a combination of several renewal and replacement projects for an overall renovation of the existing Borough Building. The work would include replacing the boilers, asbestos abatement in the boiler room and existing flooring, installing new flooring, and upgrades to various mechanical and electrical building components. It is anticipated that this will be a phased multi-year project beginning after the School District relocates its offices. This project is currently on hold pending the review of the use of the facilities fund for renewal and replacement projects. Page 6 of 30 Engineering and Facilities Update to the Assembly AGENDA ITEM #2.a. Kodiak High School Renovation/ Progress Photos /June 26 2014 w "1 — a. ,uei' w tie. ,t e � ..s � � ! .�i ■■■ a k l .L� Bp b t is £d l "+ r h i t rhx t' r ' 4i »d : " » 1W� t .4� r �.{ ? s Y,p;,�;,r.Y.-.- y top^' y't '` i.,..... f• �e ".M' "..—Exterior.. ..,...a- '< x tai. 4, 5' P, ' Exterior demo of Cafeteria and interior of Area B _ �� °" : f«a . i 1i 11%f 4}{ t - 4 5 t iy '°`'ate { . 0,Ii d` '� x » I. +r1 11 F. 3 ; ek.' .. .1f _ -...- a riY. _ f ' , 1j ttt .. i( _\ ":l: f d� t l ''.yi . i. 4.444-1 Y I `� �tr }+^ i. Fj xi<•,a,;,‘14„11' d' �5` lU. u a l 1 Y i 1 '� M1 � 1$I � qs � Y1 ,..TF'�.=#,ei A`_ —5 'k ,... a:., _ .__._..« Si_te ,�_�, 1. 'e�vl«3 \st. Glass curtain wail and wood siding at Tower's north face Vg.1 Page 7 of 30 mbly Engineering and Facilities Update to the Asse AGENDA ITEM #2.a. Kodiak High School Renovation / Progress Photos /tune 26 2014 •s a, 't. t s°" 'Z` FF t m*'x _ 3x" t i h .. '--.,e° ,, nr L , -' yII1.a fy � -z.3`- , k �' '+3A,.n" �r 3M + yt,. z of M 'eAhti ,i"€ d l�r t ;r C °'Y .. ''may IlI�53 .i'� {' y . -; `"`. #t+�p �' 4 �'r ..,1-1:7 :c.,-t-4,,,,,:.-.,it x`7' �1 ! `L C" KY-r - J. i . s y -;y i Y,.� s x4�s c; Cam` tit/ it:;" v?r k { pit7i R } ) 5 ]� S �5 b �II a S a (4 8 �10�,[ du° � t .,_ll C ;,Ik4i4a ,p •s ,` �s 4v"��. 4 t ,4 ;i0, f � : ai s. it r *{, ,.p"' g' r rs�T s" -ern `� f� ,- -.y ' ' 11. ...SSJ,::-.? ys' k�• .. ^.,,fv $Tx �`+" " * ,�.,x '4 f "k; '. ";.4.-.47-`,. vr'flL L �Y'y� r" a '1 ,,,�� �\\" gt a y #-c- t A$n ,;f'ry,}° � b,, . " �r,f a t kit- p, . -.'`* 'ti' 8k{ EE` M �`s X R' k *u� ' s` Y . w " i... A — Area ¢r..�_. f''�. ,._l ? Area D level 2 future Mat Roam 1 Mg `�,M..�`'tt , 'fl x�' "4� -� '��.^�.-'k4vsa T* :." °"r d..,M 1 t x a>7 :,;.;A:1:,:- �jra."s''t " rta. " i -,l . .« ,ew"5 .I t s ` tom' 9M', a `." °17 , "'4 r �' w x d L {p "I' G t �,,.y ; dT'te, tl'e'''<..,„ 3cY1R- „ 'S.. ,; 2kn H ? ?.;,±�- suJ 4: ry Y§ t t r� b '. r f Pf* ', f q '- 4Th'', z5 a s 1 h >.a ,, .� i: 17;:::1 r q � , w'% a a. -: `" ° 'k- . ' Fi .,''';',,, 't+„ +aw: '.z.. -af �4 l �, tll ',T ? 3{ a _ ..O } 1.y f A Y K / C -s,-1' v �_ 'Al. Jw;, I.,- t `i a-4.-x' a g >'" 7 # �t y, 3„b; �,yY�n:} �.w.u..-._�s.w,...w ...........r._:�h__ � __.d.«.. y £ j:(� n --- 6�����*"'�tM"?�u Area D level 1 future Sports Fitness Lounge Pg.2 Page 8 of 30 Engineering and Facilities Update to the Assembly AGENDA ITEM #2.a. Kodiak High School Renovation / Progress Photos/June 26 2014 '' v2\ fir.°{t i �� 1,Ii"k,.,.t.t.,.t..,r,ct,-t,f.,,,r.p,.','.d t i'..-,:,Fi N„.:,.t 4--C:4 ten. 'e9tt Cs .w'° =p' ,. 1 r,“A� 7g�, ° p. lk kY _ (f.'+-f W.. <Sal` f�y Y{A '. ‘, 4 `i£f'+.(T ' :i A..-,,..,7,..'“,.,,'1i“.T-,t4 % : 6 l :.0t.,.",;,...,, . S5 . "7 ^ --.,..ry. 1 t, .,c, 4 . i+,1,. i .� ^ tlitz`r/ . rye. . s iF Area A Tower level 1 Cascading Commons Bleachers ii��.. t f r. :«_ S Y * 1 t V �� l��j�jyyti"1. r.' r�. � "P. ;$��i- x� { ' 4i � i ���eB�aattt jp ' z, - ®1L-Utz. .1 :. "-its‘}-..,''" � �. . Fl III , it y _ i�u 'Sv >,•• .� ,..s- Area A Tower level 2 Cascading Commons and library in the background/view from 2nd floor Corridor A200 pg.3 Page 9 of 30 Engineering and Facilities Update to the Assembly AGENDA ITEM #2.a. Kodiak High School Renovation /Progresss Photos/June 26 2014 !1 pp rp rft11;;;;;4,iftliiiii : i4 !, jj �"`� p i'lj�, i 'Irt �, , I z v e � .4 44.1.1.11ft v...situ La l w f 1 k I\3a x g , } �Y p�x `10. Area A Tower level 2 Corridor A200 looking south 1st i I5 t t �t.i?l 1 '� t p.'( , tI s j` f ,"p§ , ; --,i S n- �J 04'"''' > ;,. g' r i ti : ,� lab&,.^- g r '� J b`''''',"«,",-/.1":1-'''''- .a q ,•t � '.4rs :lit; o N Z I r _ I r r s „ ,;I\ t t g 3}, F 1 jy� „Y .11„,.',437.,,a5„,.,`e `uf e...t$� °F i' ' i , girt r414,,„4,...-.1111/4\43,1.1:%111111444. rF "^ 11 P; 1 S`2r'E t,E r,' x , I ` M $q' t c .1 3+, nc...-'Z.' y& � - ( „,A1.. ...1/-* ,, _� 'a ! , S y, j r 2 1. -- � � . a rY` s' -t t ' f� J G X { V �i Y i , �,.E t' ;; 71� .p� ti f p -.-?v� n'. ! iL '� 'Jy '�W 71t x . v e ` d 1'x' :$1:._;:„, a-f"� 1 s t ! ` •f. ? ♦ „� c , 4'. •n� r d , : � � c- � " U 'ktr, "&r .a • '$ k E f(.4t y R z i{ Area A Tower level 2 Corridor A200looking north Pg.4 Page 10 of 30 Engineering and Facilities Update to the Assembly AGENDA #2.a.GENDA IT Kodiak High School Renovation/ Progress Photos/June 26 2014, 1/74:71‘tntiCA. ze. :';',.e„.„4„..L-'''' '-'5--%1 t7,f FRi{ ... �'.-C-sue^ y a�fal4, ava ''.a"` y'rpf'aiCSE'jtd'.7I� �.^"� G II ply a�✓ pr,�Tvr 4}2;t"#'NV +��1 ,�� ..�.. ' l� �`k.t } �tR^ �t.4-'--� ������ �� M 3� " 3t1 t ,g ,dry, } "' Y i A is 1- , apA" : . e xjEfl - •' ) - . a rf.—� t •. �a 1t „ �tcr.�':,.r a"Y'�y� rC ., � :: C � r ae a Area A Tower level 2 Libra Circulation Desk {{ "- -i( • tkt� .�'7`}y�rkro�ytl7 ,cn mm 6�S - tf I - , I ' ;2 r -' ` cc 3Fy' s �� rs` C` ° > N. f7,$),P, .% ati A) .. �._ v r �.s„ " t- f, as r R . �. tv.. . . 3r'i ( s rte' " . �- ,„... , ,4..: '''''Ii t '-- i ?9 � ,.2 d3 . 4' #1' .St ii ## 8i P., . w "err c Ir ,., t„ "*^ _ ate"`."$` x .?i a �'., ��, RSS az Ica v t .,7• �'��a t� ' a -s r�9 Area A Tower level 2 Corridor A203 (level 2 commons) pg.5 Page 1 c'30 Engineering and Facilities Update to the Assembly AGENDA ITEM #2.a, Kodiak High{School Renovation / Progress Photos/June 26 2014 lr� � A " V' ;� 3 't .l M rr rt ; it s it 4 mot , c� ' : ,, , .d'* ,z ` st' t > 3 a± t y,x 'S i AMR i a 4, e ,ate ', ¥ Sy g s^.µ.}.nay Si vMi Wes,$ � d Al— Y a L _ : �t»< ,- i,- „. r�a+:t yam-. y... it '�^"� .t^5f.��y �> o e-"�Yi" E Wr '�'�yy° 'f� g w ��M i . y.�°?,g�`� `i�, . i �� . w�hlx� wgryv, � - (pp � � '-«.may �„- � �„ `ter _ t ,+ r ^. .as r m Area A Tower level 4 restroom/ceramic tale progress j ,yT "'�"i` .� ."y u C{ 7 N v R 4 rt. "T ,fr-. iii x t � K Y`, '' °S.. Y _` k -.2x. ..1 M . ,, t= w -"'"+--...,_ N +t� ire s w.i -&' �^- ,�.. ."° "-�"- F .« mo . _°�+'e-�F= ( ut 3 t . a rsii d` i I 744;r1114 M yE d_��yeu = �1 f � 1 i �j,4;w r`.(`-''-;;; , ?L i a"4'.,++ . —,.,.. ,r_ w i?.:1 :<s f *erg ., ,,y, 1 } i 4Y y�Wxc b xy s! .. A �..� i 1 i 2 g?y�Ftil.!i ;7 lt:'F I ! At 'F4H"'.. rA T Area A Tower level 2 Classrooms A224& A225 pg.6 Page 12 of 30 Engineering and Facilities Update to the Assembly AGENDA ITEM #2.a. Kodiak High School Renovation /Progress Photos/June 26 2014 _ � `t� t ''v2_ , w-1= P ' °' w-iS .r z$$.—.v j .W � j�e x4 j ,"1'14 ti v. a ? ds id I dr'yy` 2/light Area A Lower level 3 Classroom A32in: •rogress L _ " -� l mo, -„Trf. t_i : 5w' q 9 I ._ 1 I, . 3 3a r?(;1'14 { _ 4 JA .�' 4b d 4 .t xt 4 ,b ta''^ ` }d 4 il k^ S'a,4 , • � Y Area A Tower level 3 Classroom A316{Media Arts) pg.7 Page 13 of 30 Engineering and Facilities Update to the Assembly AGENDA ITEM #2.a. Kodiak High School Renovation / Progress Photos/June 26 2014 } ¢� � 1 tillt` i+`3 rE A4 'x f 1111 t lie 4 lr g � . 5 IN, i !; Ifs cay� (r � I, li I d ` l ,r l Area A Tower Elevator installation progress 77 d'" -.A.- " 'S' row'""°-,..,r � a li 'S *l `..gy m ✓r` a r' IC,: ,.,Y ii w j a i ,,t �� -g `� t ., "'..:: v'u+, is .A r 0 n R 'Yk l 4,1.,,,,,:r a. f, tc li _,. : )ipi .,,.,.,�. �+-'n .d Vie, �. refit 3 .__ +—L 'I ^"_,.{. AI■ III t ?— }+C+f4.'^ `G y to a 7 171.11:tt r . 4Fi ':rj '; ` `"A�.A-4s� I jx i #� � ai if'iull t-tt St I(, i� , t `, :ii „ a I�'f` t}�F�4 ?p i ,� � 'V,tt¢ � ,y'Y4,t tt� i$'�W f r: '..* A#t < b :‘,1,:%;74,4.`,..-',"W8'„,74 V 1'ttFr ` 'a� �i 77 `1 {i SZ . I I " ea '. .41-‘,..:;'^4 ^t -a,� $ %4,..' ci rs.. '1 r°°°`2 t s 'u. ' Pt.. v u o -5 ! t 2. '�° i Rt ''tee — _~ 4te, `e 3 yA. G$ny rf.` � '. w �.Wd'Y '� ".�� Tt a .. C w i 6`� Area A Tower!eve(1 Framing continues at 80%complete pg.8 Page 14 of 30 Engineering and Facilities Update to the Assembly AGENDA ITEM #2.a. Kodiak High School Renovation / Progress Photos/June 26 2014 _ " ia.�e5'. ,t4 �i°" } o-n .ei b vF*z -'ofd r 1 i _ _ x y .., f t .'� �^�3' �A 1 ' ' = ''‘.2 =pi . ;1/41::—..' '...;1';.-11 I.1 4:1 :4„,11P-':''''..7.-7.-- -.--:y a F Yi } .. F rt� - �� b Xg .gym °D} ' // iy, Vy F�`*xs sy4t :111.lti- tea ki. Progress in West Parking Lot /view from level 4 VC f q0.'' NJySCsegy .' '0. k " jK W# P4 4 Y h F '. ,L.-4- y� ix°^`x ' e ' d n x # �:va s 3 oc:". a.itx .�. "4.42-'.�. f saes )d3 d 4' I M((„„ ��Z--`?r� P 't '44. 4 ^ .'�Yx i i kr� �T. $9 ^' x� Sri Fa . sny. 'A u +.t V '-' rv` T "i ` '- - f �.9 ,p .'. ( 4 A Exterior walkways/concrete placement 6/26/14 pg.9 Page 15 of 30 Engineering and Facilities Update to the Assembly AGENDA ITEM #2.a. Page 16 of 30 Engineering and Facilities Update to the Assembly AGENDA ITEM #2.b. Kodiak Island. Borough * „-.97-- „,fr \ OFFICE of the MANAGER ;tff r Bud Cassidy, Borough Manager V, anI 1' ce ' ; MEMORANDUM Date: June 18, 2014 To: Mayor Friend and Members of the Assembly From: Bud Cassidy, Borough Manager Re: Funding of R&R Projects! G.O. Ballot Measure Introduction The Assembly has had many discussions and has voiced a number of concerns about using the Facilities Fund (Shuyak Fund) as a source for inter-fund loans to fund R&R projects. There is an equally strong sentiment from the Assembly that KIB facilities are a substantial public investment that should be maintained. This memo will attempt to outline some options for funding for continued funding of R&R projects. Renewal and Replacement (R&R) Program and Projects A good definition of a Renewal and Replacement program is the following: A systematic management process to plan and budget for known cyclic repair and replacement requirements that extend the life of the building and retain usable condition of facilities and systems and are not normally contained in the annual operation. Another way to view an R&R program is a review of the various "building systems” to determine if obsolesces of their component parts have occurred. These "building systems" include heating and cooling (HVAC), building exterior (roof & exterior walls) or the mechanical, electrical or plumbing (MEP) of a building. By looking at KIB buildings at the systems level, separately and more intensively, parts can be changed if they are wearing out or parts can be replaced if there is a change in the part that makes the system more efficient. Bob Tucker's memo to me dated October 23, 2013 and attached does a good job of explaining a Renewal and Replacement program. Funding of an R&R Program Given the costs developed by Engineering and Facilities staff to fund an R&R program, (approximately $2,000,000/year) there is a need for a reliable source of money. Up until recently that source has been the Facilities Fund. That fund has been used two ways. The first is defined in KIBC 3.10.120(D) where investment income may be used for "maintenance and repair of existing borough facilities". Though this is an avenue for Page 17 of 30 Use of Facilities Fund for Interfund Loan AGENDA ITEM #2.b. maintenance money, little of that investment income has been used for maintenance. Most has been used for debt service or insurance. The other way that the facilities fund has been used is as the source of an inter-fund loan. An inter-fund loan from the Facilities Fund has been used for many projects since it was created. As of this date, the facilities fund has always been paid back . . with the required interest. A loan is identified at a term of 20 years and at an interest rate that is determined by the Finance Director. A spreadsheet showing those loans is attached with this memo. The Assembly has approved a list of R&R projects as well as set aside approximately $2,000,000 a year for the last 4 years. That list of projects and their status is attached. Those projects that are on hold" will continue to be so pending the resolution of where the money will come from if not from the facilities fund. A couple of other sources are: A. Major Maintenance Project List submitted to DEED. A list of projects and their backup are submitted to DEED each year by the KIBSD along with lists from all school districts around the state. DEED rates and ranks projects based on priorities like health and safety. The governor decides the level of funding that will be applied to that list in his budget. Those that are funded are done so at 70%. In the past KIB projects have made the cut and were funded. Lately, the KIB projects have not been rated or ranked very high compared to the lift/safety needs of other school districts. B. Continue funding with inter-fund loans There is fund balance in a number of funds (General Fund, Debt Service Fund, and Facilities Fund). Inter-fund loans from these funds are permissible. The money is paid back to the originating fund based on an established interest rate. The term is 20 years. Use of inter-fund loans is done commonly by municipalities around the state. The Facilities Fund has been the fund of choice because of the balance in the fund. Staff has acquired legal opinions on this very issue from two different attorneys about its legality. Both attorneys' opinions state that making an inter-fund loans from the facilities fund are allowable upon passage of an ordinance stating that is the desire of the Assembly. That ordinance should be specific though identifying the amount the term and the interest rate. Those legal opinions can be found in the Clerk's Office. Because non-school projects (Borough building projects) are not reimbursable by the state, these projects cannot be included in any General Obligation bonds ballot measure. An inter-fund loan is a valid method of funding these projects. C. General Obligation bond for School projects — Ballot Measure The State of Alaska reimburses 70% of voter approved bonds for major maintenance projects (R&R projects with the exception of painting are considered major maintenance projects). The passage of voter approved bonds is a great source to fund an R&R program. There is still the need to come up with the 30% local requirement. A word of caution though . . . this program and its benefits were looked at by the most recent legislature this Page 18 of 30 Use of Facilities Fund for Interfund Loan AGENDA ITEM #2.b. session to be reduced or eliminate. The bill that would change the existing program was not passed. Conclusion Maintaining our million dollar public facilities asset should be a priority. The goal of our renewal and replacement program as well as preventative maintenance efforts is to make our structures last beyond their 50 life span and in such a way that they are operating efficiently. Such an effort requires staff and stable revenue source. Finding money from non-tax sources is important, but when it comes down to it, local taxes will be required. It is recommended that the Assembly approve placing before the public a ballot measure to fund renewal and replacement projects for school facilities in an effort to acquiring 70% reimbursement from the State of Alaska. Staff will put together a list of R&R projects for you to review. It is also recommended that fund balances in the various funds, including the Facilities Fund be used to match the 30% local match requirement for bond projects and to fund non bond projects. Such action will require specific Assembly approval by ordinance of the project cost, term and rate of interest. Page 19 of 30 Use of Facilities Fund for Interfund Loan AGENDA ITEM #2.b. KODIAKISLAND BOROUGH Miry - - t Engineering& Facilities Department Catweck \ NT+ MEMORANDUM DATE: October 23,2013 TO: Mayor and Assembly FROM: Bob Tucker, Acting E:/F Director CC: Bud Cassidy,Manager RE: Renewal and Replacement Program The Borough started our renewal and replacement(R&R)program in 2010. The first initial list was for$36 million in R&R projects spread out over 10 years. In this case we are talking about R&R projects,not deferred maintenance projects,in most cases our projects are not deferred maintenance projects. In other words these are not projects where maintenance was ignored causing the project to become larger. However_we do have some major maintenance items in our program that could become deferred maintenance if they are not funded in time. A good case in point would he our exterior painting projects,these are major maintenance and not deferred maintenance. However,if projects like those are not funded they can quickly turn into a siding projects which is now a deferred. maintenance item. This is something we are trying to prevent with our program. Most of our R&R projects are projects where the system has met its useful life,basically it is worn out. When we started this program we began with our largest and most important assets,our education facilities. We then went on to our larger faeilities and are now working on getting our smaller buildings into the program.This is a long and involved process. + The first phase is to look at each building. In many cases the buildings where built with additions over many years,these additions need to be broken out into separate R&R schedules. Basically if each addition of a building was built 10 years apart then each part would tear out at different times.Therefore we need a separate schedule b r each addition of each building. You can see where this could get very contusing and difficult to calculate. • The second phase of the program is to break the additions down into systems that need to be renewed or replaced such as electrical,plumbing roofing and so on. Once these systems get broken down they become the projects. We then need to complete budget estimates on each project. • The third phase is project ranking according to several categories;fire,life safety,protection of structure and so on. Once the category ranking is completed then we rank them according to priority. This is done in conjunction with School District Staff and Borough Staff so that all parties involved have a say in the priorities. This has worked very well over the years making this a very useful document for planning purposes. Once we have our renewal and replacement schedule ranked and prioritized we bring it in front of the Assemble to obiaM funding for the scheduled years projects and to have you folks check our prioritization.This list is a living document of projects that are added to and re-ranked each year with the help of the end users of the facilities. Originally in 2010 the Borough received a grant reimbursement ofapprox.$3 million f r the Middle School Seismic project and used these funds for the first year. In 2011 the Borough Assembly set out that they would fund this program out of the facilities fund at$2-3 million for each year. Page I of'2 Page 20 of 30 Use of Facilities Fund for Interfund Loan AGENDA ITEM #2.b. I am here tonight to talk about this further and to let you know that this program is working. It is making a difference and needs to be funded further into the future.We still have millions of dollars' worth of projects on the list. However what you Iblks have already done is making a big impact on the bottom line. I have attached a spread sheet to show what we have completed in each year and what we have fimded,as well as what we are asking for next fiscal year. We are now in the middle of another big build out of new facilities that will need this program in the future. If we stop now then what we already have f sr projects on the list will grow out of control. We will then end up with a bigeer problem in the end if you folks don't keep this program alive. We must take care of the assets that we already have so that we can take care of the assets to come in the future. I will he at the next meeting to discuss this further and answer any question you night have about the program. Page 2 oft Page 21 of 30 Use of Facilities Fund for lnterfund Loan AGENDA ITEM #2.b. �1�° Kodiak Island Borough /4, -L . _i MEMORANDUM TO: Kodiak Island Borough Mayor and Assembly THROUGH: Bud Cassidy, Borough Manager FROM: Karleton Short, Finance Director SUBJECT: Facilities Fund loans DATE: January 3, 2014 There has been some discussion about how both the corpus and interest earnings of the Facilities Fund can be used. There have also been discussions on how expenditures in the R& R project fund will affect the mill rate. Per Borough Code,only 85%of the previous year's interest earnings can be used for debt service, property insurance and capital projects. Only 50%of these earnings can be used for Debt Service. These amounts are shown on the income statement as transfers out. The Facilities Fund has loaned money to the K.F.R.C., Bayside Fire Department,the hospital enterprise fund, to Womens Bay Fire District, and others. These are not considered transfers out. These loans are shown on the balance sheet as loans to the various entities. As these loans are paid the Facilities Fund receives both the principal amount due plus interest. These loans can be paid for by an outside revenue source or a transfer in from another fund. An outside revenue source is generally a property tax but can also include State grants or other revenues derived from entities outside of the Borough. The School District applies for the R&R projects, not the Borough as per the State regulation. The R&R projects are then scored and ranked by DEED. Then the governor usually funds a portion of the list. If we score high enough on the funding list and if the Governor funding hits one of our projects on the ranked list,then we have the potential to be reimbursed for 70%of these types of projects. The School District can submit any of our completed projects for up to 3 years after the completion of the project. One of the reasons we have been completing projects first with other funding sources and then submitting for reimbursement is that a completed project always scores higher than an uncompleted project. This is because they know your budgets are good and design is complete. Doing it this way we have a better chance of getting reimbursed from DEED. Page 22 of 30 Use of Facilities Fund for Interfund Loan AGENDA ITEM #2.b. The Borough can also transfer funds to pay for part of these project expenditures. I believe that the Facilities Fund can only fund an ongoing project, not loan expenditures after the project is complete. Other funds may make transfers into the R& R fund to reduce loan expenditures. In the past the Borough has considered these inter-fund loans as investments in a political subdivision of the State of Alaska,to include the Borough and any of its component funds. There has been some discussion on whether or not these loans will cause the mill rate to be increased. There is a cost to doing these projects. These costs can be paid for by state grants, transfers in from other funds, property taxes and other sources that may become available. As Borough debt is being retired as bonds mature the debt service payments that were going to these debts can be spent on the new debt service. A good example of this is the retirement of hospital debt. Future interest earnings on Facilities Fund investments will have a huge impact on the mill rate needed to pay off these loans. If the Borough can earn 3.5%interest the Borough can make these loan payments without raising the current mill rate. The Borough has earned between 2 and 6 per cent interest on Facility Fund investments. As an option the Borough can invest in a 10 year, non-callable Federal agency instrument, such as a FHLB, to earn 5%. However, even though the interest rate is set and will not change the market value of this instrument may change leading to"book losses or gains"which can show interest earnings both above and below the 5% interest the Borough will earn over the life of the investment. While the Facilities Fund does not pay the costs of the inter-fund loans it does pay for the debt service on our general obligation bonds reducing the need to make these bond payments from property taxes. 2 Page 23 of 30 Use of Facilities Fund for Interfund Loan AGENDA ITEM #2.b. FY Project Complete Budget Status FY10 Auditorium Roof Y $936,490 High School Parking Lot Paving Y $486,486 High School Fire Alarms Y $243,933 High School Boiler Gun Units CANCELLED $124,800 Demo Old Chiniak School Y $104,000 Ahkiok Sewer Line Y $72,800 East Close(in place)&Replace UST Y $66,194 COMBINED EAST GenSet Boro.Build.Replace Air louvers Y GRANT Middle School Close(in place)&Replace UST N $66,194 COMBINED USTS Boro.Build.Power Distribution Panels COMBINED $0 COMBINED BORO REHAB Main Canopy Replacement Y $50,059 Boro.Build.Sidewalk and Handrail Repairs Y $43,407 Boro.Build.Lighting Y $0 Grant Total $2,194,363 FY11 Boro Build.Boiler Combustion Air Fan COMBINED $0 COMBINED BORO REHAB Karluk Remove UST Y $412,931 Karluk HVAC Controls Y $59,400 CliiniakRemove&UST N $142518 IN,PROGRESS Boro.Build.New Roof Y $1,190,020 East Generator&Building Y $1,281,537 Partial grant for genset Total $3,086,406 FY12 East&Peterson Flooring N $738,504 ON HOLD Boro.Build.Return Air duct for 2nd floor N COMBINED BORO REHAB Boro Bldg &North Star Exterior Paint HALF $357,127 Port Lions Remove UST N COMBINED USTS Main Remove UST N COMBINED UST'S Boro. Build.New Receptacles N $0 COMBINED BORO REHAB Larsen Bay Roof Y $598,200 Total $1,693,831 FY13 KMS Elevator Controls N $51,840 ON HOLD Middle School HVAC Controls N $1,537,255 _ Peterson HVAC Controls N $624,427 Total $2,213,522 Page 24 of 30 Use of Facilities Fund for Interfund Loan AGENDA ITEM #2.b. FY Project Complete Budget Status FY14 None Approved by Assembly Total $0 FY 15 Port Lions Exterior Paint N $127,700 PROPOSED KMS Rear Parking Paving N $415,363 PROPOSED Auditorium Flooring foyer and hall N $141,505 PROPOSED Boro.Build.Asbestos under Carpet $233,730 PROPOSED Boro.Build. New Flooring N $267,120 PROPOSED Boro.Building Boiler Room Upgrades $21,704 PROPOSED Boro Buolding Relocate Fuel oil piping $40,068 PROPOSED Boro.Build.Move Gen Set COMBINED $392,299 PROPOSED Boro.Build Replace Boilers COMBINED $400,190 PROPOSED Boro.Build.Asbestos Boiler Room COMBINED $75,000 PROPOSED Boro.Build DDC Controls . COMBINED $441,298 PROPOSED Total $2,555,997 Borough Building Combined Boro Buld.Exterior Paint $162,275 ON HOLD Boro.Build.Power Distribution Panels $55,561 ON HOLD Boro Build. Boiler Combustion Air Fan $21,637 ON HOLD Boro.Build.Return Air duct for 2nd floor $269,895 ON HOLD Boro.Build.New Receptacles $63,052 ON HOLD Boro.Build DDC Controls $441,298 PROPOSED Boro.Build.Move Gen Set $392,299 PROPOSED Boro.Build Replace Boilers $400,190 PROPOSED Boro.Build. New Flooring N $267,120 PROPOSED Boro.Build.Asbestos Boiler Room $75,000 PROPOSED Boro.Build.Asbestos under Carpet $233,730 PROPOSED Boro Buolding Relocate Fuel oil piping $40,068 PROPOSED Boro.Building Boiler Room Upgrades $21,704 PROPOSED Total $2,443,829 Page 25 of 30 Use of Facilities Fund for Interfund Loan AGENDA ITEM #2.b. R&R PROJECTS 2010 Model 2010 Model 2015 Model Status FY15 DEED Reimbursable Projects Middle School UST $66,194 On Hold East Flooring $648,747 On Hold Peterson Flooring $363,268 On Hold Port Lions Remove UST $76,130 On Hold Main Remove UST $64,260 On Hold KMS Elevator Controls $51,840 On Hold Middle School HVAC Controls $1,537,255 On Hold Peterson HVAC Controls $642,405 On Hold KMS Rear Parking Paving $415,383 East Cafeteria Roof $840,319 $1,200,456 New Ouzinkie Old Flooring $47,462 $67,803 New Ouzinkie New Flooring $25,924 $37,034 New Akhiok Flooring $64,215 $91,735 New North Star HVAC $705,609 $1,008,013 New Middle School Fire Alarm Replacement $262,469 $374,955 New East Interior Renovation $445,347 $636,210 New Port Lions HVAC Controls $283,431 $404,902 New Larsen Bay Old HVAC Equip and Controls $616,945 $881,350 New Peterson Parking Lot Paving $434,385 $620,550 New Total $3,450,099 Non Reimbursable Projects Port Lions Exterior Paint $127,700 Auditorium Flooring foyer and hall $141,505 Boro.Build.New Receptacles $63,052 On Hold Boro.Build.Exterior Paint $162,275 On Hold Boro.Build.Return Air duct for 2nd floor $269,895 On Hold Boro. Build.Power Distribution Panels $55,561 On Hold Boro Build.Boiler Combustion Air Fan $21,637 On Hold Boro. Build.Relocate Fuel Oil Piping $40,068 Boro. Build.Boiler Room Upgrades $21,704 Boro.Build.DDC Control system $441,298 Boro.Build. New Flooring $267,120 Boro.Build Replace Boilers $400,190 Boro.Build.Asbestos Boiler Room $75,000 Boro.Build.Move Gen Set $392,299 Boro.Build.Asbestos under Carpet $233,730 Total 2010 Cost Model On Hold Total 2010 Cost Model New Projects $4,022,519 $3,726,105 Total 2014 Cost Model New Projects $5,323,007 Difference Between 2010 Cost Model and 2014 $1,596,902 Total 2015 request I $2,555,997 Page 26 of 30 Use of Facilities Fund for Interfund Loan AGENDA ITEM #2.b. FY Project Complete Budget Status FY10 Auditorium Roof Y $936,490 High School Parking Lot Paving Y $486,486 High School Fire Alarms Y $243,933 High School Boiler Gun Units CANCELLED $124,800 Demo Old Chiniak School Y $104,000 Ahkiok Sewer Line Y $72,800 East Close(in place)&Replace UST Y $66,194 COMBINED EAST GenSet Boro.Build.Replace Air louvers Y GRANT Middle School Close(in place)&Replace UST N $66,194 COMBINED UST'S Boro.Build.Power Distribution Panels COMBINED $0 COMBINED BORO REHAB Main Canopy Replacement Y $50,059 Boro.Build.Sidewalk and Handrail Repairs Y $43,407 Boro.Build.Lighting Y $0 Grant Total $2,194,363 Pill flora Build.Boiler Combustion Air Fan COMBINED $0 COMBINED BORO REHAB Karluk Remove UST Y $412,931 Karluk HVAC Controls Y $59,400 Chini3kRetnoye`.UST__ ' `. N ' ._$192!518. : [N;PROGRESS _. Bora.Build.New Roof Y $1,190,020 East Generator&Building Y $1,281,537 Partial grant for genset Total $3,086,406 FY12 East&Peterson Flooring N $738,504 ON HOLD Boro.Build.Return Air duct for 2nd floor N COMBINED BORO REHAB Boro Bldg &North Star Exterior Paint HALF $357,127 Port Lions Remove UST N COMBINED USTS Main Remove UST N COMBINED UST'S Boro.Build.New Receptacles N $0 COMBINED BORO REHAB Larsen Bay Roof Y $598,200 Total $1,693,831 FYl3 KMS Elevator Controls N $51,840 ON HOLD Middle School HVAC Controls N $1,537,255 Peterson HVAC Controls N $624,427 Total $2,213,522 Page 27 of 30 Use of Facilities Fund for Interfund Loan c N cG a -4, T a) x7 tU Current Interfund Loans 0.o ` , :., .. _ _t,. . .-. Total Interest Final Payment Beginning Outstanding Annual Interest Source of Loan • Loan Date rate Date Balance Balance Payments Income Funds [Tnnity'Acres Paving Loan' 10/31/20O5 +4180% '10/31'/2014 $ 216r69Ot $ 2 `477" $ 2'-6},266—$: -7-45196_8f,:Property Taxes z kFRC 1101%1997 7'.00%) 30/1/20181 j,000'00o 3,094W0 750000, '7(659;400 Lease1Reven ies r Hospital 7/1/2003 4.00% 6/30/2023 1,600,000 567,195 116,000 739,567 Lease Revenues o tu R&R loan 1 7/1/2012 4.50% 6/30/2032 225,603 210,752 17,226 118,914 Property Taxes m (R'&tRiIoan12 _________3/1/2013'. __v _..,. 7_/1/2013' 4150% '6130/2033- 1 588'652+ ...1'563;746; '160;650; 837;371 j $ 11,630,945 $ 5,458,770 $ 970,082 $ 9,400,620 Possible Inter-Fund Loan Sources `Fundy , ;. Na`rid General Fund $3,793,690 -_.__._..... .._.__._._.__.,......._,_....._..__.�...., Land Fill 7,324,785 KFRC 4,102,258 IN w *C)) Ca N +c., CO O O to o zi, En N p. AGENDA ITEM #2.b. • 2014 Proposed Bond Projects Tram Sob ti 't` Project Name Old Costs Status New Costs Port Lions Exterior Paint $121,700 On Hold $130,863 Middle School UST $150,000 On Hold $150,000 East Flooring $648,747 On Hold $648,747 Peterson Flooring $363,268 On Hold $363,268 Port Lions Remove UST $200,000 On Hold $200,000 Main Remove UST $150,000 On Hold $150,000 KMS Elevator Controls $54,000 On Hold $54,000 Middle School HVAC Controls $1,457,211 On Hold $1,457,211 Peterson HVAC Controls $642,405 On Hold $642,405 KMS Rear Parking Paving $415,383 2015 $649,763 East Cafeteria Roof $1,200,456 New $1,200,456 Ouzinkie Old Flooring $67,803 New $154,127 Ouzinkie New Flooring $37,034 New $38,983 Akhiok Flooring $91,735 New $91,735 Middle School Fire Alarm Replacement $374,955 New $374,955 East Interior Renovation $636,210 New $636,210 Peterson Parking Lot Paving $620,550 New $900,000 KMS Ramp Roof $109,964 $109,964 Peterson Boilers $300,510 $300,510 Main Gym floor Replacement $217,734 $416,576 Main Exterior Paint $205,438 $205,438 Peterson Exterior Paint $250,365 $250,365 Karluk Flooring $72,945 _ $85,644 Chinlak Playground $80,000 $100,000 Karluk Playground $80,000 $100,000 Akhiok Playground $80,000 $100,000 East Old Plumb Fixtures $133,410 $253,436 Old Harbor Play Grounds $120,000 $120,000 Ouzinkie Play Grounds $120,000 $120,000 Port Lions Play Grounds $120,000 $120,000 Old Harbor Remove UST $200,000 $200,000 Project Totals $10,193,794 70%State Reumbursiment $7,135,656 30%Local Contribrution $3,058,138 Remaining Projects Old Costs Status New Costs Larsen Bay Playground $120,000 Ouzinkie Old Elect Lighting $121,190 Ouzinkie Old HVAC Equip $509,101 Port Lions Flooring $169,419 Port Lions HVAC Controls $404,902 North Star HVAC $1,008,013 Ouzinkie HVAC Controls $186,706 Middle School Gym Floor Replacement $365,385 Page 29 of 30 Use of Facilities Fund for Inter-fund Loan AGENDA ITEM #2.b. 2014 Proposed Bond Projects Remaining Projects Project Name Old Costs Status New Costs Larsen Bay Old HVAC Equip and Controls $881,350 Larsen Bay Old HVAC Equip $459,084 Larsen Bay Old HVAC Controls $168,363 Larsen Bay Exterior Paint $155,451 Larsen Bay Old Elect Lighting $139,429 Larsen Bay Old Interior Doors $97,841 Larsen Bay Old Windows $27,223 East Old Exterior Doors $51,015 Auditorium Exterior Doors $81,624 Peterson Boiler Plumb Piping $9,559 Karluk Gen Exterior Doors $5,646 Chiniak Teacherage Exterior Doors $1,644 Old Harbor Generator and Building $1,006,943 Larsen Bay Flooring $378,864 Middle School Exterior Paint $320,085 Karluk Elect Lighting $147,255 Ahkiok Exterior Paint $71,473 Chiniak Exterior Paint $65,634 Larsen Bay Old Play Grounds $51,200 Karluk Exterior Doors $28,673 Old Harbor HVAC M/u Air Dist $19,961 Port Lions HVAC M/U Air _ $19,961 N Chiniak Teacherage Exterior Paint _ $9,700 Chiniak Gen Exterior Paint $5,690 Ahkiok Gen Exterior Paint $5,633 Karluk Gen Exterior Paint $5,633 Port Lions Generator and Building $920,120 East Interior Paint $274,856 Main Interior Paint $264,702 Port Lions HVAC Cont $534,470 Maintenance Elect Lighting $258,989 Maintenance HVAC Controls $156,703 Port Lions Interior Paint $154,466 Larsen Bay Interior Paint $126,660 Ouzinkie Exterior Paint $124,321 Ouzinkie Interior Paint $122,543 Old Harbor Exterior Paint $122,256 Old Harbor Interior Paint $107,310 Ahkiok Interior Paint $67,382 Chiniak Interior Paint $60,882 Chiniak Play Ground $70,000 Larsen Bay Old Remove UST $34,954 Chiniak Ext Doors $29,569 Total $19,729,956 Page 30 of 30 Use of Facilities Fund for Interfund Loan KODIAK ISLAND BOROUGH WORK SESSION /3190A. tt1l,f ►ME1 Sm J/Vork Session of: C,t+a a 24/ ,9-7)/y Please PRINT your name Please PRINT your name ••\ 0 , 4/, • . ~• t. V V