Loading...
1985-09-05 Regular MeetingKODIAK ISLAND BOROUGH ASSEMBLY MEETING - September 5, 1985 (A Verbatim Record is on File in the Clerk's Office.) I CALL TO ORDER Mayor Peterson called the meeting to order at 6:40 p.m. in the Borough Assembly Chambers. II ROLL CALL Present Absent Mayor Peterson Ms. Barker Mr. Blankenburg Mrs. Cater Mr. Naughton Mr. Rounsaville Mr. Wakefield Mr. White A quorum was established. III ACCEPTANCE OF AGENDA *A. CONSENT AGENDA Consent Agenda items are items considered to be routine and non -contro- versial by the Assembly and will be approved in one motion. There shall be no separate discussion of these items unless an Assembly member or a citizen so requests, in which case the item will be removed from the Consent Agenda and considered in its normal sequence on the agenda as part of the General Orders. Consent Agenda items will be prefixed in the margin with an asterisk (*). Mr. Naughton moved to accept the agenda with the addition of August under X NEW BUSINESS item N. Seconded by Mr. Wakefield. Mayor Peterson suggested the following additions under VI COMMUNICATIONS & APPEARANCES item C. Removal of Personnel from Boards & Commissions and item D. Housing Advisory Boards memo in reference to Lab Policy of Kodiak Island Hospital. Mr. Wakefield so moved and Mr. Naughton seconded. Motion carried by unanimous voice vote on the amended agenda. IV MINUTES OF PREVIOUS MEETINGS *A. Assembly - Reg. - August 1, 1985 Mr. Naughton moved to adopt the minutes of the previous meeting. Seconded by Mr. Wakefield. Motion carried by unanimous voice vote. V MINUTES OF OTHER MEETINGS *A. K.I.B. School District - Reg. - July 22, 1985/Spec. - Aug. 13, 1985 *B. Womens Bay Service District - Reg. - July 11, 1985 *C. Fire Protection Area #1 - June 4, 1985/June 28, 1985 *D. Planning & Zoning Commission - Reg. - July 17, 1985 *E. K.I. Mental Health - June 24, 1985 *F. Kodiak Economic Development Committee - June 17, 1985 *G. Personnel Advisory Board - July 1, 1985 Mr. Naughton moved to acknowledge receipt of items A through G. Seconded by Mr. Wakefield. Motion carried by unanimous voice vote. VI COMMUNICATIONS & APPEARANCES A. Boards & Commissions 1) Tim Hill - P & Z Commission representative 2) Lorna Arndt - Personnel Board representative B. Award to Chevron Hank Pennington presented an award, on behalf of the Borough, to Chevron for the cooperation with Kodiak Island Borough and Outer Continental KIB Assembly Mtg. - Sept. 5, 1985 Page 2 Shelf Committee during the recent oil well drilling activity in Shelikof Straits. C. Removal of Personnel from Boards & Commissions Mr. Wakefield moved to remove Mrs. Lorna Arndt from the Personnel Board in accordance with Kodiak Island Borough Code Section 2.10.025. Seconded by Mr. Naughton. Motion carried by unanimous voice vote. Mr. Wakefield moved to remove Mr. Scott Arndt from the Service District #1 Advisory Board in accordance with Kodiak Island Borough Code Section 2.10.025. Seconded by Mr. Naughton. Motion carried by unanimous voice vote. J D. Memo from Medical Staff re: Lab Policy of Kodiak Island Hospital Ms. Barker moved to acknowledge receipt. Seconded by Mr. Wakefield. Motion carried by unanimous voice vote. *** BOARD OF ADJUSTMENT A. Appeal of Planning and Zonings denial of a request for an exception from Section 17.17.020 (Permitted Uses) of the Borough Code to permit an existing duplex dwelling on a lot in RR1, Rural Residential One, district. Lot 8, Block 1, Mountain View Alaska Subdivision, First Addition; 1679 Three Sisters Drive. (Mark White - Applicant & Appellant) (Res. No. 85-80-R) Mayor Peterson closed the regular meeting and reconvened as the Board of Adjustment. Linda Freed, Director of the Community Development Department, gave the staff presentation. This case came before the Community Development Department as a result of a complaint from a property owner in the area. The evidence and reasons being relied upon by the Commission include: 1) A building permit issued to Mark White on April 1, 1982, for a single family residence on Lot 8, Block 1, Mountain View Alaska Subdivision, First Addition. 2) A certificate of occupancy issued on April 19, 1983, for a single family residence on Lot 8, Block 1 Mountain View Alaska Subdivision, First Addition. 3) A site inspection by Mike Steele on March 18, 1985 which is cited on page 2 of a letter from Mr. Steele to Mr. White on April 17, 1985 identifying the use and design of the structure on Lot 8, Block 1 as a duplex. 4) Kodiak Island Borough code section 17.06.220 which states that a dwelling unit is defined as: "One or more rooms and a single kitchen in a dwelling designed as a unit for occupancy by not more than one family for living or sleeping purposes and in which not more than two persons are lodged for hire." 5) Duplexes are not an allowed use in the zoning district which Lot 8, Block 1 Mountain View Alaska Subdivision, First Addition is located. 6) Adverse public testimony. Tim Hill: (P & Z Commissioner) I spoke with Mr. Steele prior to the public hearing and he informed me that since he is no longer employed by the Borough and would also be out of town at the time of the public hearing, he would not be attending the meeting. Mr. Bryce Gordon inspected the building and gave it a certificate of occupancy because it was partially constructed and it was enough for occupancy of a family. After the certificate was granted, Mr. White went in and completed the duplex. Mr. Mark White: (Appellant) In essence, I think we have a problem with semantics and definitions. You have before you my letter recently written containing about six pages of refudiation to the three findings of fact. Again, I don't agree with the findings of fact. Again, the bottom line is that there are three related people living in this structure at this point. As I mentioned before in my letter, I'm quite willing to agree in writing to limit the population of the structure for the occupancy rating of the structure to less than five as permitted by the code in the single family dwelling. Because I, in fact, thought I was constructing a single family dwelling. I also, agree not to increase the size of the structure in any way. VP1 1" KIB Assembly Mtg. - Sept. 5, 1985 Page 3 Mickey Mummert: I am an immediate neighbor to one of Mr. White's lots. I feel that Mr. White is in really flagrant disregard of the present code requirements. I am very much against you granting this variance. Cathy Cordry: I also live in Monashka Bay. I would just like to say that a duplex is a duplex, no matter what you call it. A duck is a duck, whether you call it a Mallard or a Pintail. Dan Maciak: I am supporting Mr. White. I think Mr. White is trying in a reasonable effort to accomodate and to correct the situation. I think his effort reflects it and I'm here to request an exception be granted. Mr. Mark White: (rebuttal) I think that people that live in glass houses probably shouldn't throw stones. Mr. Wakefield moved to adopt Resolution No. 85-80-R Affirming The Planning And Zoning Commission Decision Concerning A Request For An Exception To Allow A Duplex To Remain In An RR1 District for the following reasons: A. The proposed use will endanger the public's health, safety or general welfare, as the duplex will increase the permitted density of the lot by a factor of two. Additionally, no permits have been issued or inspections performed for the conversion to a duplex to ensure compliance with building and fire codes. 2) The proposed use will be inconsistent with the general purposes and intent of Title 17 and with the specific description and intent of Chapter 17.17, the RR1, Rural Residential District. 3) The proposed use could potentially adversely impact other properties in the area. Granting this exception will set a precedent for changing the use, density, and expected life- style (i.e., large lot, low -density, single-family residential) of the subdivision and the RR1 zoning district. Seconded by Mr. Blankenburg. Motion carried 5-2 with Mrs. Cater and Mr. Naughton casting the NO votes. Mayor Peterson closed the Board of Adjustment and reconvened the regular meeting. �! VII PUBLIC HEARINGS (Village Telephone Number 486-5370) A. Res. No. 85-79-R Disposing Of Certain Borough Lands To The Kodiak Island Housing Authority. Mr. Naughton moved to adopt Resolution No. 85-79-R. Seconded by Mrs. Cater. Regular Session closed: Public Hearing opened: Marlin Knight: (Executive Director of K.I.H.A.) I am here to speak in favor of the land disposal (Block 3 Lakeside Subd., 1st Addition) to Kodiak Island Housing Authority for residential development. K.I.H.A. proposes to transfer $598,200 in funding to Kodiak Island Borough to offset the water, sewer and road costs in return for the site being requested. I believe this is a fair arrangement for both. Our analysis of all the sites that responded to our advertisements indicated that the project would not be financially feasible due to the severe restrictions we are bound on the purchase of property. The project proposed is a mutual help home ownership opportunity program. We believe this project is worthy of your favorable consideration and we hope you agree with us. Gordon Pullar: (Pres. of Kodiak Area Native Assoc.) I wish to go on record as endorsing the efforts of the Kodiak Island Housing Authority in trying to find a way for people to become homeowners who wouldn't ordinarily have the opportunity to be homeowners. I urge your favorable consideration to their request. Clarence Selig: I would like to state that the plan presented to the Borough Assembly regarding certain lands sought by the Kodiak Island Housing Authority in my estimate is quite an equitable deal. Rather than industrial, I would like to see it as an extension of the inner Selief extended outward as residential and public lands. I hope the Assembly, after weighing all testimony, stands firm with their original concept of the Beaver Lake Lakeside Subdivision plan as attested to the resolution this evening. �1I 1 :1 KIB Assembly Mtg. - Sept. 5, 1985 Page 4 John Hartman: I am speaking in favor of the land disposal to the Kodiak Island Housing Authority. It would be a method for me and my family to try and obtain property here. I would like to think of it as a form of affordable homes. It would be something I can call my own. Ken Parker: I am here to speak in favor or the disposal of the land to Kodiak Island Housing Authority. I see this program as an opportunity to be able to get the home that my family needs. I strongly support this program. Gloria Cabbob: I too am in favor of the disposal of Borough land to the Kodiak Island Housing Authority. Like the other participants, this is the only chance that we'll ever get to purchase out own home because of the cost of property. Stacy Pullar: I too am in the same position that the others are in. I have children and I am also seeking an education for better employment. Without this program, my family and I wouldn't be able to own our own home. Cliff Vogelsberg: I am lucky enough to live in Kodiak and have a house here. I don't have any problem at all with the housing project. I think it is a good deal for Kodiak and for all the people that can't afford to own a home any other way. Scott Arndt: I wish to speak opposed to the proposed use not the disposal of the property. If they were really looking at trying to contribute to the economy, it would be more appropriate to break it up into tracts of two, four or six and put them out to bid. That's the only way that you are going to get bids from the local contractors in town. The large bid bonds or performance bonds are impossible to get. With the current number of tax exempt properties that you have currently on the books, you are going to create an effect where the taxable property is going to be carrying more and more of the burden and I do not think that is fair. I do not think you should enter into this agreement at this time unless there are some drastic modifications made to the agreement. Maureen Butler: I live at the end of Selief Lane. I was at the last P & Z meeting when they voted to make the lots in question industrial. I don't understand the issue of the disposal at this meeting tonight, if they haven't handled the zoning of that property yet. I think that one issue has to be taken care of before the other one can be handled. It is a big conflict between residential and industrial back in that area and I don't feel the two are compatible, especially if you're going to put high density zero lot line development back there. I'm not saying that I'm totally against the Kodiak Island Housing Authority building a project like this, even in my neighborhood. I feel that Kodiak needs to be more informed about what we are talking about. I am against the development at this time until they organize the area back there better. Pat Briggs: I do agree with you that the Borough should be in the business of promoting land and getting it out and getting it developed. I know we have Borough land that would be ideal for development, but not next to a industrial park or a business zone. You have to have these buffers. Lorna Arndt: We don't need any more low-cost housing in this town. Why should the rest of us support them and pay their property taxes. I think you better think of the rest of the people that have been here and not listen to one letter you received and then ignore the rest of the people. We need industrial. Public Hearing closed: Regular Session opened: Mayor Peterson called for a five minute recess. Regular Session closed: Public Hearing re -opened: Sid Cozart: I don't believe in this not being on the tax rolls. I think we have enough burdens as it is. Disposing of this property over there where everybody is already in disagreement I just don't agree with it. It should be the concensus of the people and not just seven officials. Donene Tweeten: I think the size of the lots and the rezoning should be UI^I Ix KIB Assembly Mtg. - Sept. 5, 1985 Page 5 decided before the disposal of the certain lands in question. I again would like the Assembly to look at that residential -industrial complex back there with small buffer zones. John Parker: I would like to speak against the ordinance and see the Borough table it because I believe there is already enough data and adequate staff to really determine some of the financial impact that this is going to have on Kodiak as well as on the Borough tax rolls. Until this evening, I was under the impression that there was probably some additional properties that the housing authority would be developing in some of the outlying rural areas and I believe they have done some excellent things in those areas out there. I believe they have done with a lot of forethought and a lot of study. I believe that we are that not C seeing the same amount of forethought and study being done here so that information could be presented so that all of us could look at it as a term of equity and reasonable business practices rather than an emotional issue of who is and who is not going to benefit by it. Carol Hartman: As a hopeful participant, I hope that you will adopt this resolution to make these Borough lands available to Kodiak Island Housing Authority. There are always people out there that want freebies and I know that these programs have to try to weed people out as best they can. I think that most of the people that are in this program, that I have met and been with, feel the same way. I don't think they want to be parasites on this program. I think they want to have their own home. Dan Maciak: I do have my own house. I am for this program. I believe there is a need for this particular program. The people who would be eligible for this need would not be people who would be eligible for the traditional type of loans and mortgage payments. I support them and encourage you to pass this resolution. Alan Austerman: I think that if a little more forethought had been given to this public hearing tonight you wouldn't have quite the long public hearing you are having tonight. As far as the concept of the housing authority, I agree with it. Kodiak has an inherent problem, with its fishing industry and its economic base of needing this type of housing. You didn't give it adequate thought before you put it up for public hearing. I am not against the Kodiak Island Housing Authority. I am against the fact that this is being presented at this point in time in that area. Dennis Murray: I think without the industrial property, we really evade the question when we continue to add more property to the tax exempt status roles with the hope that we will be providing shelter to people that can't otherwise afford housing. There won't be a necessity for that if we don't have some economics. I think there are a lot of problems with this. I am not opposed to the concept. I think if you could go out and buy a $100,000 house, one in this subdivision and that one, you would encourage these people because they would be part of the general community and not isolated and segregated in one area, low cost housing. Pat Briggs: I don't quite understand when Mr. Knight says, no he can't make his program meet an $86,000 duplex or zero lot line where ever they are building. Dennis Murray: I would just like to give you one final thought, and that is what will you do about fire protection in this area. I think that is another issue. It's outside the city limits, not in any service district and it's not taxable. Public Hearing closed: Regular Session opened: Mr. Wakefield moved to table Reolution No. 85-79-R. Seconded by Mr. White. Motion carried by unanimous voice vote. VIII OLD BUSINESS A. Ord. No. 85-22-0 Amending The Kodiak Island Borough Code To Adopt Garbage And Solid Waste Collection And Disposal Powers In The Areas Outside Cities And Accept The Transfer Of Such Powers From The City Of Kodiak. (Tabled) Mr. White moved to remove Ord. No. 85-22-0 from the table. Seconded Mr. i KIB Assembly Mtg. - Sept. 5, 1985 Page 6 Wakefield. Motion carried by unanimous voice vote. Mr. White moved to table. Seconded by Mr. Wakefield. Motion carried by unanimous voice vote. B. Motion to Rescind Res. No. 85-68-R. (Rounsaville) Mr. Rounsaville moved to rescind the previous action on Resolution No. 85-68-R. Seconded by Mr. Blankenburg. Motion failed 3-4 with Mr. Blankenburg, Mr. Rounsaville and Mr. White casting the YES votes. C. Reconsideration of action on Petition. The Chair ruled that there was no material change to the consideration and therefore the petition and the effects of the petition noted by the Clerk are upheld by the Assembly. I would also like to state that legislative matters and not administrative are referendable. Mr. White moved to direct Staff to prepare a Resolution for public hearing next month to place the petition Ordinances on the Ballot for citizens vote. Motion failed 3-4 with Mr. Blankenburg, Mr. Rounsaville and Mr. White casting the YES votes. D. Motion To Rescind Action On Ord. No. 85-28-0 Rezoning Portions Of Miller Point Area. (1st Rdg.) Mr. Wakefield moved to rescind the action taken on Ordinance No. 85-28-0. Seconded by Mrs. Cater. Motion carried 6-1 with Mr. White casting the NO vote. Mr. Wakefield moved to amend the ordinance to indicate the zoning as listed in the Option 2 Plan. Motion carried 5-1 with Mr. White casting the NO vote and Mr. Rounsaville abstaining. IX MANAGER'S REPORT *A. September Meetings Mr. Naughton moved to acknowledge receipt Motion carried by unanimous voice vote. *B. Staff Reports Mr. Naughton moved to acknowledge receipt Motion carried by unanimous voice vote. C. Other Business Seconded by Mr. Wakefield. Seconded by Mr. Wakefield. Mr. Selby pointed out that there will be several items coming up at next months meeting that will be of high public interest. X NEW BUSINESS A. Ratification of Election Judges Mr. Wakefield moved to approve all the election judges per the Deputy Clerk's memo of September 5, 1985 for the October 1 election. Seconded by Mr. Rounsaville. Motion carried by unanimous voice vote. B. Res. No. 85-73-R Urging Alaska Legislature To Enact Legislation Giving Preferential Hire To Alaskans. Mr. White moved to adopt Resolution No. 85-73-R. Seconded by Mr. Wakefield. Motion carried by unanimous voice vote. C. Res. No. 85-74-R Recognizing And Supporting "Appreciaiton Day" For Efforts Toward Better Living In The Kodiak Island Community. Mr. Wakefield moved to adopt Resolution No. 85-74-R. Seconded by Mrs. Cater. Motion carried by unanimous voice vote. D. Res. No. 85-75-R Recommending The Disposal Of Certain Borough Properties. Mr. Wakefield moved to adopt Resolution No. 85-75-R. Seconded by Mrs. Cater. O I..V 1..1 KIB Assembly Mtg. - Sept. 5, 1985 Page 7 Mr. White moved to table. Seconded by Mr. Rounsaville. Motion failed 2-5 with Mr. White and Mr. Rounsaville casting the YES votes. Mr. White moved to table Resolution No. 85-75-R. Seconded by Mr. Wakefield. Motion carried by unanimous voice vote. E. Res. No. 85-76-R Approving The Kodiak Island Hospital Schematic Plans And Outline Specifications Prepared By Mills, John & Rigdon, Architects A.I.A.. Ms. Barker moved to adopt Resolution No. 85-76-R. Seconded by Mrs. Cater. Motion carried by unanimous voice vote. F. Res. No. 85-77-R Awarding The Kodiak Island Hospital Design Contract To Mills, John & Rigdon, Architects, A.I.A.. Ms. Barker moved to adopt Resolution No. 85-77-R in an amount not to exceed $720,000.00. Seconded by Mrs. Cater. Motion carried by unanimous roll call vote. G. Res. No. 85-78-R Awarding The Stage Lighting Instruments And Accessories Contract. Mr. Wakefield moved to adopt Resolution No. 85-78-R in an amount not to exceed $38,014.00. Seconded by Mrs. Cater. Motion carried by unanimous roll call vote. H. Ord. No. 85-29-0 Rezoning The Lakeside Subdivision Area. (1st Rdg.) Mr. Wakefield moved to adopt Ordinance No. 85-29-0 in the first reading. Seconded by Mr. Naughton. Mr. Wakefield moved to amend by changing Lots 1 through 17, Block 3, Lakeside Subdivision First Addition from RR1-Rural Residential One to R-2 Two Family Residential District and Lots 2 through 28, Block 4, Lakeside Subdivision First Addition from RR1-Rural Residential One to R-1 Single Family Residential. Seconded by Mr. Naughton. Amendment failed 2-5. Mr. White moved to table Items H through L to the Special Meeting on September 10, 1985. Seconded by Mr. Naughton. Motion failed 4-3 with Mr. Naughton, Mr. Rounsaville and Mr. White casting the YES votes. Ms. Barker moved to amend Ordinance No. 85-29-0 by changing Lots 1 through 17, Block 3, Lakeside Subdivision First Addition from RR1-Rural Residential One to R-2 Two Family Residential District and delete the last paragraph under Section 1. Amendment carried 4-3 with Mr. Naughton, Mr. Rounsaville and Mr. White casting the NO votes. Motion as amended carried 5-2 with Mr. Rounsaville and Mr. White casting the NO votes on Ordinance No. 65-29-0. Mr. Wakefield moved to extend the meeting until 11:30 pm. Seconded by Mrs. Cater. Motion carried 6-1 with Mr. White casting the NO vote. I. Ord. No. 85-30-0 Rezoning The Remaining Portion Of Tract G, U.S. Survey 444. (lst Rdg.) Mr. Naughton moved to adopt Ordinance No. 85-30-0 in the first reading. Seconded by Mr. Wakefield. Motion failed 3-4 with Mrs. Cater, Mr. Naughton and Mr. Rounsaville casting the YES votes. J. Res. No. 85-81-R Authorizing Reimbursement For Attorney Fees. Mr. Wakefield moved to adopt Resolution No. 85-81-R. Seconded by Mr. Blankenburg. Motion failed by unanimous roll call vote. K. Res. No. 85-62-R Authorizing The Manager To Negotiate Acquisition Of A Site For The New Kodiak Island Hospital. Ms. Barker moved to adopt Resolution No. 85-82-R. Seconded by Mr. Wakefield. Motion carried by unanimous voice vote. C 1-1'1 KIB Assembly Mtg. - Sept. 5, 1985 Page 8 L. Res. No. 85-83-R Requesting Completion Of A Comprehensive Plan For Shuyak Island. Mr. White moved to adopt Resolution No. 85-83-R. Seconded by Mrs. Cater. Motion carried by unanimous voice vote. *M. K.I.B. School District Financial Report - July 1985 Mr. Naughton moved to acknowledge receipt. Seconded by Mr. Wakefield. Motion carried by unanimous voice vote. *N. K.I.B. Financial Report - June, July & August 1985 Mr. Naughton moved to acknowledge receipt. Seconded by Mr. Wakefield. Motion carried by unanimous voice vote. XI MAYOR'S COMMENTS In the situation created over public hearing this evening, it is very difficult sometimes to Chair the meeting up here. I know emotions run high. I don't think it reflects very well, especially when the meetings are aired over the radio, when there are "cat -calling" attacks from people in public hearing process. I think it is uncalled for. I don't see it happening on the City level and I certainly don't see why there is a reason to do it on the Borough level. I have felt that the Assembly has made every effort in trying to look at everybody's issue on it. XII ASSEMBLY COMMENTS Mr. White: None. Mr. Rounsaville: Every citizen has their rights. It bothers me to see one citizen attacking anothers dignity. I think we all have to be aware of it and try to respect the other individual as a worthwhile individual. Mr. Wakefield: Maybe we should just scrap it all on the Lakeside Sub- division and leave it all trees. Apparantly the public doesn't want us to put land out to the other public. Personally, I am really disgusted about it. Mrs. Cater: I would like to comment a little bit on Lakeside Subdivision. I don't know of any issue, since I have been on the Assembly, that I have agonized over more. There is a difference between what I would feel personally and what I would feel as responsibility as an Assembly member. I think the Assembly has tried hard to look at the concerns of the community in that area and tried to address them. Mr. Blankenburg: None. Ms. Barker: I would like to vote to extend till 11:45 because I would like some time for public comments. Ms. Barker moved to extend the meeting until finished with public comments. Seconded by Mr. Blankenburg. Motion carried by unanimous voice vote. XIII AUDIENCE COMMENTS Maureen Butler: I had no idea that the Lakeside Subdivision was the biggest chore of the Borough Assembly. As you know, I am the one that has helped push to get the area along the lake left open. I think it is very important to this community. This community needs places like this. It's not asking for a great deal to have a few acres around a lake left open when you consider the land that can be developed by the Borough. Alan Austerman: I would like to address the economics of Kodiak. I am here to ask or recommend that maybe a resolution could be presented to the State of Alaska in reference to shellfish surveys. Maybe the Borough could take a stand in reference to asking the State to consider keeping the funding in for this type of survey. The Assembly directed Staff to prepare such a resolution . Pat Briggs: I would like to apologize to the Mayor and Assembly, I didn't mean any derogative comments. I have kind of a hang-up with low-cost housing. I would like to remind you that there must be an access to the property before putting the land up for sale. John Parker: I think overall the Borough employees, for the most part, are u l" u KIB Assembly Mtg. - Sept. 5, 1985 Page 9 very pleasurable to deal with. I feel it is very difficult for the Assembly to make decisions with minimum data. I think the Borough should feel it reasonable to ask for supporting data from individuals, whether they are private developers or municipal developers, when it comes to projects. Dennis Murray: I would suggest to you that you have a roll call vote on the controversial decisions so that the public knows where individual members of the Assembly stands on those issues. I think that when you talk about using Roberts Rules of Order you had better understand what the rules of order are and you had better also understand what the motion is. I think perhaps that first motion by Ill JI Mr. Rounsaville on the referendum petition was out of order. So to rule the second one out of order is kinda immaterial. Donene Tweeten: I would also like to request roll call votes on the crucial items. The audience can't tell who voted how. I am amazed at what is happening on Lakeside. I think you should have a work session on changing this since it was your action that you are disagreeing on tonight. I feel the whole lake frontage should be public lands. Scott Arndt: You have had a lot of issues regarding Lakeside Subdivision. You are ignoring the public testimony that has gone to Planning and Zoning. The other issue I would like to speak to is that it is my understanding that there was a vote to remove me from the Service District Boards. First off, what reason do you go ahead and make a decision while there is an appeal before you which you haven't heard yet. I have put in a letter appealing the Service District's decision. That is totally incorrect. I am not on one of your Boards or Commissions and you do not have a right to remove an elected official from another board. Lorna Arndt: I want a copy of the motion you made tonight on my removal. I want a letter by 1:00 p.m. tomorrow on this situation stating every- thing and how you can do it to me. Okey Chandler: I agree with Mr. Wakefield on the suggestion of putting in a road and leaving the front side of the lake for a park. Marlin Knight: I would like to apologize also. I hope most of you don't throw up your hands and want to forget about it. I empathize with your positions. It is a tough job. John Hartman: I am interested in property on Kodiak. I hate to see this Kodiak Island Housing Authority development project fall through. XIV ADJOURNMENT Mr. Wakefield moved to adjourn. Seconded by Mr. Naughton. Mayor Peterson adjourned the meetin� " ^^ ATTEST; Borough Deputy Clerk